Home › Forums › Labour Law Debate › DO DEMANDS AND THREATS MERIT DISMISSAL? › Reply To: DO DEMANDS AND THREATS MERIT DISMISSAL?
![](https://www.labourlawadvice.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/Ingrid-150x150.png)
In City of Johannesburg v SAMWU & others (2009)5 BLLR 431(LC), the initial demand by the union was for two managers to be suspended for interfering with certain test results, this was later changed to a demand for suspension in accordance with due process and in a manner not constituting an unfair labour practice. This demand was accepted by the court as not being unlawful. Management had, on receipt of the strike notice, asked the court to declare the intended strike unlawful. The court did not agree, finding that the modified demand made by the union was not unlawful.
On this basis, I would argue that the “threat” is not unlawful if there is a justifiable reason for their demand and that their demand was not for the factory manager to be dismissed without a hearing. In these cirumstances, therefore, the employees cannot be disciplined for making the threat. However, if they were demanding a dismissal without a hearing, that would be unlawful.